Neither Disobedients nor Rebels

Lawful Resistance in Early Modern Italy

Angela De Benedictis
Collana: Viella History, Art and Humanities Collection, 6
Pubblicazione: Luglio 2018
Wishlist Wishlist Wishlist
Scheda in PDF Scheda in PDF Scheda in PDF
Edizione cartacea
pp. 234, 15,5x23 cm, hardback
ISBN: 9788833130187
€ 55,00 -15% € 46,75
Aggiungi al carrello Aggiungi al carrello € 46,75

It is a widely known fact that during the conflict between the American Colonies and Great Britain, which resulted in independence and the birth of the United States of America, the insurgents presented their collective actions as lawful forms of resistance and defense against an unjust government in the motherland, which threatened their freedoms. They therefore did not consider themselves either disobedient or rebels. These views and these claims had, moreover, characterized early modern European history for centuries, on the basis of a shared politico-juridical culture.

This volume analyzes some Italian urban rebellions that occurred in the 16th and 17th centuries (Urbino, Messina, Mondovì, Castiglione dello Stiviere) from this perspective, emphasizing the resemblances with the Catalan (1640) and Neapolitan (1647) revolts. Fundamental problems emerge from all the cases under consideration: the borderline between loyalty and obedience, between unconditional and conditional obedience, the issue of sovereignty and its limits.

  • Aknowledgments
  • Introduction
  • 1. The Urbino Tumult (1572-1573)
    • 1. A judge’s truth and a diarist’s truth
    • 2. Agitators. The deposition of Gabriele de Beni
    • 3. Just an error, not a crime. The deposition of Vincenzo Ridolfi
    • 4. A just and clement prince, an infuriated plebs. The deposition of Alessandro Veterani
    • 5. Defending oneself with arms or asking for pardon. The deposition of Severo Paltroni
    • 6. The true reason of State and the false
  • 2. Neither Disobedients nor Rebels
    • 1. Resisting the unjust exercise of power. Self-defence
    • 2. Historical facts and juridical texts. Exemplary cases
    • 3. Delinquent communities, unpunished multitudes: the doctrine of ius commune
  • 3. Intermezzo. Performances
    • 1. The unpunishable multitude in emblem literature and in the theatre of Lope de Vega
    • 2. Representing facts in terms of law: the Noticia Universal de Cataluña (1640)
    • 3. Revolution and rebellion are not the same: Naples 1647
  • 4. War Against Rebellious Cities: Messina 1674-1678, Mondovì 1680-1682
    • 1. “To crush the proud” (“debellare superbos”): political reason against rebellious Messina 1674-1678
    • 2. Why should the universitas be punished if it had not committed a sin? Mondovì and the Salt War (1680-1682)
  • 5. Never Obey out of Fear: Castiglione delle Stiviere, 1689-1694
    • 1. The voice of the community: impossible to obey an enemy prince
    • 2. A prince may be resisted with arms. The legal advice of the jurist Antonio Gobbi
  • Conclusions
  • Bibliography
  • Index

Originally published as Tumulti. Moltitudini ribelli in età moderna. Bologna: il Mulino 2013.

All chapters and ‘Conclusions’ translated by Alexandra Mary Lawrence and revised by Robert Fredona. ‘Introduction’ translated by Robert Fredona.

Angela De Benedictis

Angela De Benedictis is a former Professor of Early Modern History at the University of Bologna up to and including the academic year 2017-2018. She is the author of Repubblica per contratto. Bologna: una città europea nello Stato della Chiesa (Bologna, 1995), Politica, governo e istituzioni nell’Europa moderna (Bologna, 2001), Tumulti. Moltitudini ribelli in età moderna (Bologna, 2013), all published with il Mulino.

Forse ti interessa anche
  • Identità politiche e appartenenze regionali fra Settecento e Ottocento
    A cura di Angela De Benedictis, Irene Fosi, Luca Mannori
    2012, pp. 302
    € 30,00 -15% € 25,50
  • Rural Societies, Aristocratic Powers and Monarchy in the 12th and 13th Centuries
    Sandro Carocci
    2018, pp. 622
    € 95,00 -15% € 80,75
  • The broken boundaries of the Renaissance
    Giovanni Ricci
    2018, pp. 190
    € 30,00 -15% € 25,50
  • Between the Councils and the Reformation
    Antonín Kalous
    2017, pp. 258
    € 35,00 -15% € 29,75