Come rondini in volo o come orsi nella foresta? : migranti, stranieri, altri
Rocco Sciarrone
Like swallows in flight or bears in the forest? Migrants, foreigners, others
The purpose of the article is to present the essays collected in this number of
the review, and some interpretations of the main issues emerging from the current
debate, practices and policies on migration and migrants. The focus is first on the
continuities and discontinuities between the past and present migratory
movements, with reference to the most important analyses and researches. Then,
the article deals with the identity and cultural diversity issues, and offers some
criticism of the debate on multiculturalism. The conclusions discuss those policies
which tend to consider and face the problems related to the migrants’ regulation
and integration following a purely security logic.
Identità migranti
Marco Aime
Migrant identities
In the contemporary rethorics of political communications the concept of
«culture» is often used in the same way the old concept of «race» was used in the
last centuries. We have a racism without race. There is a rising of cultural
fundamentalism, and the cultures are seen as solid entities, who cannot
communicate, becoause of their difference. As Regis Debray said, while the
objects are globalising, the men are tribalizing.
Gli operai, gli immigrati, la rivoluzione : Detroit e Torino : un'ipotesi comparativa (1967-73)
Nicola Pizzolato
The Workers, the Migrants, and the Revolution.
Detroit and Turin: a comparative hypothesis (1967-73)
This article examines in a comparative perspective labour migration and
workers’ struggle in Detroit and Turin at the end of the Sixties. These two cases
are well-known for the extent of radical protest that hit the automobile plants in
that period, but they have never been studied in connection. While national
studies highlighted in the Turin case issues of class and in the Detroit case issues
of race, the comparative analysis focuses on the fact that in both cases the catalyst
for a prolong period of industrial conflict were migrants. The article enquires into
the motives for the shopfloor conflict and finds them well linked to the problems
related to the quick urban change that ensued immigration and to the migrants’
quest for first class citizenship in the new context.
Spagna e Italia : lo straniero come metafora delle incertezze politiche
Evelyne Ritaine
Spain and Italy: stranger as metaphor of political incertainties
The paper developes a reflection on the political construction of immigration
matter in recent societies of immigration. It compares on this thema antipolitical
politicization process in Italy (by the Berlusconi coalition) and hyperpolitical
politicization process in Spain (by the Aznar government): the «securitization»
interpretation appears as the result of specific political opportunities and of
specific discursive opportunities, managed by nationalist and neopopulist actors.
In the two cases, this exclusive polity is a dead end: the utilitarian interpretation of
immigration comes as a way out, to make collective interests government possible.
Dai modelli alla pratiche di integrazione degli immigrati : convergenza o divergenza?
Tiziana Caponio
From models to practices of immigrants’ integration. Convergence or divergence?
Research on immigrants integration has been traditionally dominated by the
debate over national citizenship models. Yet, recent studies have pointed out the
relevance of local policies in providing crucial resources for immigrants
integration in the host society. A growing body of literature on city policies is
emerging, according to which local administrations are usually more prone to
accommodate diversity in a pragmatic way. Thus cities represent favourable
contexts for the developing of forms of soft multiculturalism. The article
discusses this thesis from a critical point of view. Actually, evidence provided by
the literature is contradictory, since local governments have also to face with non
positive attitudes towards foreigners in their local electorate. Research studies on
Italian cities show different patterns of integration policy, characterised by
various degrees of openness/closure towards immigrants. A certain convergence
is actually produced at the level of everyday practices, since civil servants and
third sector organisations have to cope with ordinary problems of service delivery
to a culturally diverse clientele.
Perdersi e trovarsi nella traduzione
Renate Siebert
Getting lost and finding oneself into translation
This paper deals with the issue of translation as metaphor of postcolonial era,
i.e. an era shaped by globalization processes and large migration movements.
These processes press for, mostly impose, a sort of «second socialization» which
firstly involves people who migrate. However, those unavoidable intercultural
relations will never be properly as such if this second socialization does not cross
also «us», the natives, the inhabitants of those countries which receive migrants.
The mutual translation among different languages and cultures plays a
preponderant role in the current world. Starting from Walter Benjamin, this
paper, in the first part, goes trough some theoretical dimensions of the concept of
translation which bring to argue that not everything is translatable and «that
particular convergence» which, according to Benjamin, characterizes translation is
not always easy to achieve. In the second part, the paper presents Fatema
Mernissi’s exemplary narrative reflection which some how stages a translation
process, by contrasting male fantasies, «eastern» and «western», and the different
social constructions of harem.
Clandestini a Lampedusa : isolati, segregati, invisibili
Alessandra Dino
Clandestine migrants in Lampedusa: isolated, segregated, invisible
Social construction processes of migrant, often clandestine migrant, among the
inhabitants of Lampedusa, have recorded, in the last years, a gradual moving from
a prevaling sympathetic optics combined with human solidarity forms – even if
not without defensive processes and forms of racism and xenophobia – to more
and more clear dynamics of exclusion. The social representation of the stranger
isn’t, however, either unvarying or coherent. Infact, the collected interviews give
evidence for continuous oscillations between the wish to understand – that
increases when there is an interaction with the strangers – and the need to defend,
even with reactions of violence and exclusion, the poor privileges and the small
eeconomic resouces (especially tourism). This situation often produce deep
contradictions between ethical instances and economic necessity. Lampedusa’s
inhabitans witnesses offer an evocative representation of these conflicts and help
to show the migrants condiction, characterized by silence, invisibility thath often
hide exclusion and ignorance of the elementary human rights.
Seconde generazioni in una scuola di Torino : la riuscita scolastica come costruzione sociale
Arianna Santero
Second generations in a Turin school: the social construction of scholastic success
Foreign pupils in Italian school constitute a structural, increasing presence.
Their outcomes are the result of a multidimensional process, influenced by
several individual and social factors. Not only the family migratory project and
the different conceptions of scholastic education, but also didactics, assessment
techniques, gender and expectations of adolescents and teachers must be
considered in order to explain the immigrant students’ results. The case study
shows how a secondary school in Turin tries to avoid the «ghettoization» by
intercultural programs, cooperation with other educational agencies, strict
criterions to pass the students. The fifteen-years-old pupils with lower sociocultural
status can obtain prestige in the peer group by a kind of opposing
culture, but often drop out of the school and lose the opportunity of upward
social mobility.
Italiani in Germania : un'intricata vicenda migratoria
Luca Storti
Italians in Germany: a complex migration story
The article paints a picture of the italian migration to Germany. With a
chronological focus it’s identified three historical phases: the first one takes place
before the First World War; the second during the Nazism regime; the third and
maybe most significant one after the Second World War, in the fordism age,
which is characterised in Germany by a hefty economic growth and by the
requirements of unskilled foreign manpower. The second part of the article
presents some statistical data about the present situation of the italian migrants in
Germany. Two issues are tried to be pointed out: 1) Italians are still signed by a
high unemployment rate and law educational level. This issue is related to the fact
that they moved frequently between the two countries, and so many second
generation Italian migrants have difficulties to develop long-term migration
projects and were not faar-seeing in job searching. 2) Italians show a high
entrepreneurship rate, with a remarkable concentration in the field of gastronomy.
Sulla capacità di essere felici : ricchezza, benessere e libertà a partire dal capability approach
Benedetta Giovanola
On the ‘capability to flourish’.
Richness, well-being and freedom in the capability approach and beyond
The paper starts with an overview on the contemporary debate on well-being
and with a comparison between the two most prominent approaches to this issue,
happiness theories and capability approach. It then assumes the latter as its
theoretical framework and develops both its meta-ethical (or methodological) and
ethical implications respectively through an inquiry into CA’s informational basis
and its ideas of public reasoning and rationality. This twofold analysis also leads
to highlight the CA’s re-definition and broadening of the concept of well-being
and its rejection of the notion of happiness (typical of mainstream economics) in
favour of the more ancient (and complex) idea of human flourishing. The paper
then develops an inquiry into the Aristotelian roots of Sen’s and Nussbaum’s idea
of «human flourishing» and connects the latter with the notions of capability,
freedom and self-realization. Finally the last section develops the philosophical
anthropology underlying the CA and highlights the notion of human richness at
the core of CA’s idea of personhood.
«Beat si vive, inseriti si muore» : l'epopea dei capelloni in Italia (1965-67)
Silvia Casilio
«Beat is to live, inserted is to die». Epos of the beat generation in Italy (1965-67)
Our story begins in 1965, when for the first time some long haired boys made
their strange apparition in Piazza di Spagna in Rome. This phenomenon firstly
appeared in the interlands of Italian metropolis and it was one of the first,
certainly one of the most original forms of «collective subjects in motion» and of
the generation rebellion in Italy. The first number of the most famous beat review
«Mondo Beat» came out in Milan, in the last months of 1966. In the same period
some curious political experiments were made and there were many protests.
From many prefectures of the North of Italy there were many informations
about the birth of «Provos» Groups and of Beat tabloids all over Italy. The term
«ad quem» is the 1967 idest the moment in which, after the Milanese experience
of the Beat camping in Ripamonti street, the movement disappeared and the
students movement came out.
Mondi nuovi
Salvatore Lupo