From models to practices of immigrants’ integration. Convergence or divergence?
Research on immigrants integration has been traditionally dominated by the
debate over national citizenship models. Yet, recent studies have pointed out the
relevance of local policies in providing crucial resources for immigrants
integration in the host society. A growing body of literature on city policies is
emerging, according to which local administrations are usually more prone to
accommodate diversity in a pragmatic way. Thus cities represent favourable
contexts for the developing of forms of soft multiculturalism. The article
discusses this thesis from a critical point of view. Actually, evidence provided by
the literature is contradictory, since local governments have also to face with non
positive attitudes towards foreigners in their local electorate. Research studies on
Italian cities show different patterns of integration policy, characterised by
various degrees of openness/closure towards immigrants. A certain convergence
is actually produced at the level of everyday practices, since civil servants and
third sector organisations have to cope with ordinary problems of service delivery
to a culturally diverse clientele.