Affectionate Condescension: The “Two Cultures” and
Anglophone Views of Italy’s Divorce Question (1900-1974)
This article examines the way the English-language press judged Italy
on its treatment of the divorce question in the twentieth century, arguing that
the fate of divorce-law proposals came to be seen as a litmus test of the true
nature of Italian culture. The introduction of divorce laws in most of the western
world by 1900 was a result of state formation and the corresponding
erosion of religious jurisdiction over private life. Although Italy had been the
bright star of liberalism in the 1860s, its refusal to introduce a divorce law
throughout most of the twentieth century was interpreted as a sign of lurking
medievalism. After World War II the continued absence of a divorce law appeared
particularly anomalous against the background of extraordinary economic
and social progress. The English-language press followed the campaigns
to introduce a divorce law in the 1960s with great interest, and when
the Italian public affirmed their support for divorce in the referendum of
1974, Italy was finally held to have shed its vestiges of medieval culture and
fully embraced progress and modernity.